|
|||
Tracking the Reasons Many Girls Avoid Science and
Math
Number Sense Correlates with Test Scores
Researchers Identify Best Strategies for
Supporting New Science Teachers
“Toward
a Systematic Evidence Base for Science in Out-of-School Time: The Role of
Assessment”
Dropout Prevention Practice Guide
Dropout and Completion Rates in the United
States: 2006
Cause of Conduct Problems Among Girls Appears to be
Different than in Boys
Internet-Based Instruction
Effective for Teaching Health-Care Professionals
Mobile Phones Help Secondary Pupils
More Than One-Third of California’s Dropouts
Eventually Finish High School
Assignment Monitoring in California of
Certificated Employees
Report Identifies Inherent Link Between a
21st Century Education System and Economic Success
Alabama’s Public Education Dilemma: Does
Funding Influence Outcomes?
New Study Assesses the Impact of Soft Drink Availability
in Elementary Schools on Consumption
National Poll on Children’s Health
School Vouchers and Student Achievement: Recent
Evidence, Remaining Questions. 2008.
Charter
Schools Supported by Public
Tracking the Reasons Many Girls Avoid Science and Math
Most
parents and many teachers believe that if middle-school and high-school girls
show no interest in science or math, there's little anyone can do about it.
New
research by a team that includes vocational psychologists at the University of
Wisconsin-Milwaukee (UWM) indicates that the self-confidence instilled by
parents and teachers is more important for young girls learning math and
science than their initial interest.
While interest is certainly a factor in getting older girls to study and pursue a career in these disciplines, more attention should be given to building confidence in their abilities early in their education, says UWM Distinguished Professor Nadya Fouad. She is one of the authors of a three-year study aimed at identifying supports and barriers that steer girls toward or away from science and math during their education. "The
relationship between confidence and interest is close," says Fouad.
"If they feel they can do it, it feeds their interest."
It's
a high-priority question for members of organizations like the National Science
Foundation (NSF) and the National Research Council as they ponder how to
reverse the rapidly declining numbers of women in STEM careers – science,
technology, engineering and math.
Many
young students, particularly girls, see math and science as difficult, and
don't take any more classes than they have to, not realizing they are cutting
themselves off from lucrative opportunities in college and careers.
The
NSF-funded study – the most highly detailed study on this topic – dug deeply to
identify the specific factors that would stoke interest.
"For
the last 20 years, there has been all this work done on boosting interest of
girls early on. But I don't think that's it," says Fouad, whose research
has found evidence that confidence levels in math- and science-related tasks
are lower for girls than for boys.
Complexity
The
study tracked girls and boys in middle school, high school and their sophomore
year in college in both Milwaukee and Phoenix, with the main goal of
pinpointing when the barriers for girls appear and how influential they are.
Co-authors include Phil Smith, UWM emeritus professor of educational
psychology, and Gail Hackett, Provost at the University of Missouri–Kansas
City.
Self-efficacy
is not the only important factor for girls, the study uncovered. Results point
to a complicated issue, says Fouad. For one thing, math and science cannot be
lumped together when designing interventions because the barriers and supports
for each discipline are not the same.
"There
were also differences at each developmental level and differences between the
genders," she says. That means interventions would need to be tailored for
each specific subgroup.
Overall,
however, parent support and expectations emerged as the top support in both
subjects and genders for middle- and high-school students. Also powerful for
younger girls were engaging teachers and positive experiences with them.
The
study confirmed that old stereotypes die slowly. Both boys and girls perceived
that teachers thought boys were stronger at math and science. For boys this
represented a support, while for girls it acted as a barrier.
Top
barriers for all age groups and disciplines were test anxiety and subject
difficulty. But these differed between boys and girls. In addition, the genders
formed their perceptions of math or science based on the barriers and supports,
but they often arrived at different views.
Ultimately,
it's perception, more than reality, that affects the person's academic and
career choices, says Fouad.
Scholarly
clout
That's
the take-away message from her more than two decades of work. A
fourth-generation college professor, Fouad studies cross-cultural vocational
assessment, career development of women and minorities, and factors motivating
people to choose certain careers.
She
and Smith were among the first teams of researchers to empirically support a
model that identified the prominent role that self-confidence and outcome
expectations play in predicting career interests.
The
next step in the NSF study on girls, and math and science is to examine the
relationship between barriers and supports, and then to widen the view to
include women who are not working in those fields despite having an educational
background in math or science. Fouad received funding from UWM on this project
and has just received a half-million-dollar grant to focus on women in
engineering.
Nationally,
20 percent of graduates with degrees in engineering are women, she says, but
only 11 percent of engineers are women. Her inquiry will explore the reason for
the gap.
Number Sense Correlates with Test Scores
Knowing
how precisely a high school freshman can estimate the number of objects in a
group gives you a good idea how well he has done in math as far back as
kindergarten, researchers at The Johns Hopkins University found.
Good
"number sense" at age 14 correlates with higher scores on
standardized math tests throughout a child's life up to that point and weaker
"number sense" at 14 predicts lower scores on those standardized
tests, said Justin Halberda, assistant professor of psychological and brain
sciences in the university's Krieger School of Arts and Sciences.
"We
discovered that a child's ability to quickly estimate how many things are in a
group significantly correlates with that child's performance in school math for
every single year, reaching all the way back to when he or she was in
kindergarten," Halberda said.
Halberda
teamed up on the research with colleagues Michèle Mazzocco, associate professor
of psychiatry and behavioral sciences in the Johns Hopkins School of Medicine
and researcher at the Kennedy Krieger Institute, and Lisa Feigenson, also a
Johns Hopkins assistant professor of psychological and brain sciences. The
results of their investigation are scheduled for advance online publication by
the journal Nature at http://www.nature.com on Sept. 7.
Though
people often think of mathematics as a pinnacle intellectual achievement of
humankind, research reveals that some intuition about numbers, counting and
mathematical ability is basic to almost all animals. For example, creatures
that gather or hunt for food keep track of the approximate number of food items
they procure in order to return to the places where they get the most
sustenance. Humans share this very basic "number sense," allowing
them, at a glance, to estimate the number of people in a subway car or bus,
Halberda says.
The
Johns Hopkins team wondered whether this basic, seemingly innate number sense
had any bearing on the formal mathematics that people learn in school. So the
researchers asked 64 14-year-olds to look at flashing groups of yellow and blue
dots on a computer screen and estimate which dots were more numerous. Though
most of the children easily arrived at the correct answer when there were (for
example) only 10 blue dots and 25 yellow ones, some had difficulty when the
number of dots in each set was more nearly equal. Those results helped the researchers
ascertain the accuracy of each child's individual "number sense."
They
then examined the teenagers' record of performance in school math all the way
back through kindergarten, and found that students who exhibited more acute
number sense had performed at a higher level in mathematics than those who
showed weaker number sense, even controlling for general intelligence and other
factors.
"What
this seems to mean is that the very basic number sense that we humans share
with animals is related to the formal mathematics that we learn in
school," Halberda concludes. "The number sense we share with the
animals and the formal math we learn in school may interact and inform each
other throughout our lives."
Though
the team found this strong correlation between number sense and scholastic math
achievement, Halberda cautions against concluding that success or failure in
mathematics is genetically determined and, therefore, immutable.
"There
are many factors that might affect a person's performance in school mathematics,"
Halberda says, "What is exciting in our result is that success in formal
mathematics and simple math intuitions appear to be related."
Future
directions for research include investigating the trainability of one's number
sense and seeing whether early help in number sense could affect later formal
math learning.
Researchers Identify Best Strategies for Supporting New Science Teachers
With a nationwide shortage of science teachers and plummeting
student test scores, many school districts are forced to hire teachers with
science degrees but little training in education or experience teaching.
Without proper support, research shows that 66 percent of new teachers will
quit the profession within three years. Now, new research from George Mason
University’s New Science Teachers’ Support Network (NSTSN) has identified the
most vital forms of support for new science teachers—providing them with
in-classroom support and quality courses in how to teach science.
The
NSTSN, created by researchers at George Mason University’s Center for
Restructuring Education in Science and Technology (CREST) with funding from the
National Science Foundation, chronicled the experiences of uncertified teachers
in three Virginia school districts and the people supporting them to determine
how the new teachers’ needs were addressed and the consequences of those
actions.
“Teachers
have a daunting task. They must be instructional leaders, curriculum and
assessment experts, special needs advisors, cheerleaders, educational
visionaries and change agents,” says Donna Sterling, founder of NSTSN. “Growing
expectations for teachers to successfully teach a broad range of students with
different needs and steadily improve achievement mean that classrooms and
teaching typically must be redesigned rather than merely continuing as in the
past.”
Working
with middle and high school science teachers, the NSTSN research revealed that
students enrolled in the classes of teachers who received the support of
in-class mentors who were retired science teachers and a science teaching
course performed significantly better on standardized tests and had better
science grades than students enrolled in the classes of a comparable set of new
science teachers who did not receive the in-class support from retirees or a
science methods course. Also, by enlisting the help of retired science
teachers, new science teachers were able to perfect their teaching and enhance
student learning.
“Retired
master science teachers are one group not to overlook as a source of support
because many have the skills, knowledge and time to work with new teachers,”
says Wendy Frazier, associate director of CREST and program manager on the NSF
grant. “Not only can retirees observe classroom teaching and provide support
throughout the school day, but they can identify when a teacher is being
treated poorly and serve as an advocate.”
Free
of the constraints of teaching their own students, retired science teachers
have both the time and the knowledge to make a difference. Retirees are able to
help new teachers plan effective lessons, identify strategies and
organizational ideas for laboratory activities and model effective teaching
techniques during a lesson.
Studies
have shown that teacher attrition can be reduced through attention to improving
new science teachers’ working conditions. Through improved working conditions,
new science teachers are provided the time they need to learn how to teach
well.
In
addition, the NSTSN makes the following recommendations.
·
Assign new teachers only
one class preparation so they have time to reflect and revise lessons between
class periods to perfect their teaching skills.
·
Provide new science
teachers their own classroom instead of having them float between classrooms
with a cart.
·
Establish a plan and
identify a person or team to provide new teachers with an orientation to the
school, policies and procedures.
·
Provide
teaching resources, including teaching supplies, computer equipment and science
equipment, along with a trainer to demonstrate effective equipment use.
“Toward a Systematic Evidence Base for Science in Out-of-School Time: The Role of Assessment”
Politicians,
educators, and business leaders alike emphasize the critical importance of
scientific literacy among citizens for both individual and national success in
the 21st century. Yet, research indicates that by most measures, our system of
science education is not working. Middle school and high school students are
performing poorly on international tests when compared to their peers in other
developed nations. In addition, few undergraduates are choosing to major in
science or engineering (15% in the United States, as compared to 47% in France,
50% in China, and 67% in Singapore). Moreover, students report low levels of
interest in science classes in middle and high school.
In
response to this need to enhance both the quality and quantity of science
education in the U.S., practitioners, researchers and policy-makers have begun
to expand the role of informal science learning as a venue to promote science
literacy and engagement. This strategy focuses increasingly on the large
potential of out-of-school time (OST) settings, which include programs that
occur after school and during the summer. After-school and summer programs
typically provide an environment where exploration can take place in a more
relaxed, experiential, and test-free setting.
Moreover,
a chief reason for low levels of interest in science among students in the
United States is that school science often feels disconnected from students’ lives
outside of school. Because the after-school setting exists in between the world
of school and students’ homes and communities, it is in a privileged position
to address this perceived disconnect, offering science programs that may be
more personally and contextually relevant than those that are driven primarily
by defined curricula and tests.
There
is considerable philosophical overlap between after-school programs and
informal science education. Youth development research has shown ideal
after-school settings as student-centered and providing opportunity for
cooperation and relationship-building while developing knowledge and skills
through authentic, handson activities. Similarly, ideal informal science
programs are described as hands-on, learner-directed, and interactive in the
context of a social group and consisting of cooperative activities and
real-world tasks.
While
there are many reasons to believe after-school programs can play a significant
role in increasing students’ interest, engagement, knowledge and achievement in
science, the evidence that after-school science programs are succeeding in
these goals remain sparse. In the past decade, there have been increasing
numbers of independently commissioned evaluations of science after-school programs.
The data from these studies are very promising, indicating that after-school
science programs can improve students’ attitudes towards science; increase
their scientific knowledge and skills; and, in some cases, raise grades, test
scores, and college attendance. Participation in science after-school and
summer programs has also been correlated with increased likelihood of selecting
science-related college majors.
To
date, many of the studies that show promising results have used “homegrown”
assessment tools to demonstrate impact. Although this practice has its benefits
(e.g., instruments relate directly to a specific program), it results in two
challenges. First, the use of program-by-program assessments calls into
question the validity and/or reliability of the studies (since they
traditionally lack norms, psychometric properties, and peer-reviewed reports),
and this can render them less persuasive in the eyes of researchers, funders
and policymakers. Second, because many programs and program evaluators create
their own tools, it is difficult to compare or summarize results across
programs or evaluators. As a consequence, there is very little comparative data
available to support the claim that OST science programming is effective, or to
support best practices for the field. It should be noted that other
applications of informal science, particularly in museum science, have a
voluminous body of evaluation research.
Furthermore,
there are several organizations that make available an open source for evaluation
findings studying informal science (see informalscience.org,
visitorstudies.org, and the National Science Foundation’s Informal Science
Education website). While these sites do not focus specifically on after-school
science, they demonstrate the accumulation of a large body of collective
knowledge of the informal science field. Yet even in this more mature field,
the evaluations remain, for the most part, quite focused on individual
projects, and they rarely can be generalized or used to compare data across
programs.
The
field of after-school and summer science is at a critical juncture. Interest in
and federal funding for after-school programs has surged over the last decade.
In 2005, 40% of all students in grades K-8 were in at least one weekly non-parental
after-school care arrangement. Yet in order for the field to continue to grow
and improve in quality, research and evaluation efforts must keep pace.
Increasingly, funding is contingent upon programs’ capacity to show evidence of
their success. Consequently, there has been an increase in the number of
instruments created to evaluate individual programs.
Although
the use of these instruments has already made significant contributions to the
assessment of after-school science programs, the field is now at a point where
it is necessary to examine critically what are the most efficacious and
efficient means of assessment, whether these assessments should differ across
programs, and how they should relate to constructs of science learning and
program quality.
To
address these fundamental questions, the Noyce Foundation, a leading funder in
the after-school science field, invited this study, review and report to better
understand the current state as well as the needs of the after-school informal
science assessment world.
Complete
report:
http://www.pearweb.org/research/pdfs/Assessment+of+Science+in+OST.pdf
Dropout Prevention Practice Guide
This new practice guide from its What
Works Clearinghouse formulates specific and coherent evidence-based
recommendations that are intended to be useful to educators in high schools and
middle schools, to superintendents and school boards, and to state policymakers
in planning and executing dropout prevention strategies.
Guide:
http://ies.ed.gov/ncee/wwc/publications/practiceguides/
Dropout and Completion Rates in the United States: 2006
This report builds upon a series of
National Center for Education Statistics (NCES) reports on high school dropout
and completion rates that began in 1988. It presents estimates of rates for
2006 and provides data about trends in dropout and completion rates over the last
three decades (1972-2006), including characteristics of dropouts and completers
in these years. Report highlights include: The averaged freshman graduation
rate (AFGR), which provides an estimate of the percentage of public high school
students who graduate with a regular diploma 4 years after starting 9th grade,
was 74.7 percent for the class of 2005. Students living in low-income families
were approximately four times more likely to drop out of high school between
2005 and 2006 than were students living in high-income families. In October
2006, approximately 3.5 million civilian noninstitutionalized 16- through
24-year-olds were not enrolled in high school and had not earned a high school
diploma or alternative
credential.
To view, download and print the report
as a PDF file, please visit:
http://nces.ed.gov/pubsearch/pubsinfo.asp?pubid=2008053
Cause of Conduct Problems Among Girls Appears to be Different than in Boys
The
first study to include a significant number of aggressive girls with conduct
problems indicates that psychological conditions including conduct disorder may
have separate causes in the two sexes.
The
research reaffirmed that boys 8 to 12 years of age diagnosed with conduct and
oppositional defiance disorders have lower heart rates and sweated less while
at rest and playing a video game for money compared to boys without these
conditions. However, girls of the same age exhibited the same physiological
responses whether they did or did not have conduct problems.
“Previous
studies have focused on boys because boys with conduct disorder outnumber girls
by a 10-to-1 ratio,” said Theodore Beauchaine, a University of Washington
associate professor of psychology and lead author of the study. “We went out of
our way to find girls with conduct problems because we thought something
different must be going on since there is such a big difference in the number
of boys and girls with conduct disorder.
“Our
findings suggest we had better start studying girls differently than boys. We
can’t assume the same processes are at work in boys and girls. When there are
different mechanisms it suggests there should be different treatments.”
In
the study, UW researchers took physiological measurements – focusing on the
autonomic nervous systems that controls and regulates such involuntary body
functions as heart rate, blood flow, and the workings of muscles and glands –
of 110 boys and 65 girls while they played a computerized game. About half of
the boys and girls met the criteria for conduct and/or oppositional defiant
order. The other boys and girls had no psychological problems.
The
game had the children, who were seated at a monitor, look a number that
appeared on the screen and then press the same number on a keyboard. A correct
response enabled them to win money. The faster and more accurately they played
the more money could earn.
“It
was not unusual for some children to make $50 playing this game, which is a
considerable amount of money for kids of these ages,” said Beauchaine. “Normal
boys get pretty excited while they play, but boys with conduct problems don’t.
However, we found no differences in the way the groups of girls responded.”
Biological
markers that seem to make boys more vulnerable to conduct problems appear to be
largely inherited, according Beauchaine.
“We
know impulsivity is 80 percent inheritable and these markers go along with
sensation seeking. So boys inherit this low arousal from their parents. This
doesn’t mean they will have conduct disorder, but it puts them at risk for it.”
He
added that the failure to find a biological marker among girls with conduct
problems suggests that this behavior is driven by different causes. They may be
strong social or environmental influences such as ineffective parenting or
simply hanging around the wrong kids.
Conduct
problems typically begin with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder in young
children. Some then develop oppositional defiance disorder in elementary
school. This behavior is marked by talking back to parents and teachers and
refusing to do what adults say. This cycle of behavior problems ends at this
point for most children, but in middle school a small number go on to develop
conduct disorder that is much more severe and can include such behaviors as
stealing, property damage and, in extreme cases, arson and cruelty to animals.
Internet-Based Instruction Effective for Teaching Health-Care Professionals
A
study led by a team of education researchers from Mayo Clinic and published
this week in the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA) concludes that
Internet-based education generally is effective.
Lead
author David Cook, M.D., an associate professor of medicine who practices
general internal medicine at Mayo Clinic, worked with researchers from Mayo and
McMaster University in Hamilton, Ontario. They reviewed more than 200 studies
about Internet-based instruction. The researchers concluded that Internet-based
instruction is associated with large learning gains compared with no
instruction. The research also showed that Internet-based instruction compared
favorably to traditional instructional methods.
"Our
findings suggest that Internet-based instruction is an effective way to teach
health care professionals," says Dr. Cook. "We now can confirm that,
across a wide variety of learners, learning contexts, clinical topics, and
learning outcomes, Internet-based instruction can be as effective as
traditional methods."
Dr.
Cook also notes that Internet-based instruction has unique advantages,
including flexible scheduling, adaptability of instruction, and readily
available content that is easily updated. "As health care workers balance
challenging practice demands, the ever-expanding volume of medical knowledge requires
us to find more effective, efficient ways to learn," says Dr. Cook.
"Internet-based instruction will be an important part of the
solution."
He
also notes that this research likely applies to training outside of health
care, citing studies in the engineering, computer science, and teaching fields
that have shown similar results.
Mobile Phones Help Secondary Pupils
Ask
a teacher to name the most irritating invention of recent years and they will
often nominate the mobile phone.
Exasperated
by the distractions and problems they create, many headteachers have ordered
that pupils must keep their phones switched off at school. Others have told
pupils to leave them at home.
However,
education researchers at The University of Nottingham believe it is time that phone
bans were reassessed — because mobile phones can be a powerful learning aid,
they say.
Dr
Elizabeth Hartnell-Young and her colleagues have reached this conclusion after
studying the consequences of allowing pupils in five secondary schools to use
either their own mobile phones or the new generation of 'smartphones' in
lessons.
During
the nine-month experiment, 14 to 16-year-old pupils used the phones for a wide
range of educational purposes, including creating short movies, setting
homework reminders, recording a teacher reading a poem, and timing experiments
with the phones' stopwatches. The smartphones, which could connect to the
Internet, also allowed pupils to access revision websites, log into the school
email system, or transfer electronic files between school and home.
The
research involved 331 pupils in schools in Cambridgeshire, West Berkshire and
Nottingham.
"At
the start of the study, even pupils were often surprised at the thought that
mobile phones could be used for learning, " Dr Hartnell-Young will tell
the annual conference of the British Educational Research Association in
Edinburgh today. "After their hands-on experience, almost all pupils said
they had enjoyed the project and felt more motivated."
Some
teachers also had to reassess their views even though staff who took part were
already champions of new technology in their schools. "Students like
mobiles and they know how to use them," one said. "Using this
technology gives them more freedom to express themselves without needing to be
constantly supervised."
Other
teachers found that pupils who lacked confidence gained most from the project.
However, they recognised that greater use of mobile phones in schools could
prove problematical.
Increased
temptation to steal phones was one worry. "I thought, well, four of these
smartphones are going to end up on eBAY tomorrow," one teacher said.
That
fear turned out to be misplaced but a few teachers remained concerned that
phones could prove a distraction for some pupils. Allowing pupils to access
school emails via mobiles would also pose data security risks if passwords were
shared, they said.
Teacher
unions have similar fears and have supported phone bans in schools.
"Pupils nowadays come to school equipped with mobile phones, MP3 players,
and portable games consoles when teachers would like them to just bring a
pen," Chris Keates, general secretary of the NASUWT teachers' union, said
last month.
Dr
Hartnell-Young says that the teachers' worries are understandable. "While
the eventual aim should be to lift blanket bans on phones we do not recommend
immediate, whole-school change," she said.
"Instead
we believe that teachers, students and the wider community should work together
to develop policies that will enable this powerful new learning tool to be used
safely. We hope that, in future, mobile phone use will be as natural as using
any other technology in school."
More Than One-Third of California’s Dropouts Eventually Finish High School
Thirty Four Percent of High School Dropouts are
Not in School and Not Working
The
latest report from the California Dropout Research Project (CDRP) looks at what
happened to students from the graduating class of 2004 who dropped out after
tenth grade. The study finds that, two years after their scheduled graduation,
37 percent of high school dropouts in California eventually complete high
school, with 21 percent earning a regular diploma, and another 16 percent
earning an alternative credential—a General Education Development (GED). In
addition, 17 percent were still in high school or pursuing a GED. Compared to
the rest of the nation, high school completion rates of California’s dropouts
were significantly lower.
The
report, entitled What Happened to Dropouts From the High School Class of
2004?,
also found that two years after their scheduled graduation, 34 percent of high
school dropouts in California were neither going to school nor working.
The
report is the latest in a series of 24 policy and statistical briefs on
California’s dropouts conducted by CDRP, a research program based at the
University of California, Santa Barbara. In February of this year, the CDRP
Policy Committee—composed of researchers, policymakers and educators—released a
state policy agenda identifying short-term and long-term recommendations for
improving California’s high school graduation rate.
The
latest and all previous reports can be viewed at http://www.lmri.ucsb.edu/dropouts/.
Assignment Monitoring in California of Certificated Employees
Between
September 2003 and June 2007, 6.3 percent of certificated employees were in a
position for which they did not
hold an appropriate credential or authorization. A total of 22,352 certificated
employees were initially found to be placed in unauthorized assignments. While
this figure is more than double the 9,112 initial misassignments identified in
the last report cycle (1999-2003), the increase appears to be the result of
additional scrutiny rather than an increase in actual misassignments.
The
added emphasis in reviewing assignments for the teachers of English learners is
a result of the Williams settlement in 2004. The unauthorized assignments
of these teachers of English learners account for more than half of the total
misassignments reported and this category of misassignments increased by more
than 88 percent from the previous report cycle (1999-2003).
Complete
report:
http://www.ctc.ca.gov/commission/agendas/2008-08/2008-08-4B.pdf
Report Identifies Inherent Link
Between a 21st Century Education System and Economic Success
Creating a 21st century education system that prepares students,
workers and citizens to triumph in the global skills race is the central
economic competitiveness issue currently facing the United States, according to
a new report released by the Partnership for 21st Century Skills.
The report, 21st Century Skills, Education & Competitiveness,
finds that the United States, in order to be globally competitive and for
states to attract growth industries and create jobs, requires a fresh approach
to education that recognizes the importance 21st century skills play in the
workplace.
Sponsored by the Partnership for 21st Century Skills, Ford Motor
Company Fund, KnowledgeWorks Foundation and the National Education Association,
the report notes that the country’s economic output has changed dramatically
over the past 30 years and there is no sign this trend will stop.
In 1967, the production of material goods (cars, equipment, etc.)
and delivery of material services (transportation, construction, etc.)
accounted for nearly 54 percent of the country’s economic output. However, by
1997, the development of information products (computers, for example) and the
provision of information services (financial and broadcast services and others)
accounted for 63 percent of the country’s output. As the world continues to
shift from an industrial economy to a service economy driven by information,
knowledge and innovation, cultivating 21st century skills is vital to economic
success.
While the global economy has been changing, the United States has
focused primarily on closing domestic achievement gaps and largely ignored the
growing necessity of graduating students capable of filling emerging job
sectors. This remains a legitimate and worthy agenda but still dangerously
discounts the global competitiveness issue.
“Equally important to the domestic achievement gap, is the global
achievement gap between United States students – even top-performers – and
their international counterparts,” said Paige Kuni, worldwide manager of K-12
education for Intel Corporation and chair of the Partnership for 21st Century
Skills. “Quite simply, for the United States to stay economically viable and
remain a world leader, the country must make closing all achievement gaps a
national priority.”
Abroad, developed and competing nations have focused on imparting
a different set of skills – 21st century skills – to their graduates because these skills increasingly power
the wealth of nations. Furthermore, businesses now require workers who can
handle more responsibility and contribute more to productivity and innovation.
In fact, from 1995 to 2005, the United States lost three million manufacturing
jobs, but, during that same time, 17 million service-sector jobs were created.
It is critical that the United States graduate students capable of filling
those jobs and keeping pace with the change in skill demands.
“Through my work with the business community, it has become
apparent that there isn’t a lack of employees that are technically proficient
but a lack of employees that can adequately communicate and collaborate,
innovate and think critically,” said Ken Kay, president of the Partnership for
21st Century Skills. “At this pivotal moment in our nation’s history,
legislators and policymakers must focus on the outcomes we know produce
graduates capable of competing in the 21st century and forging a viable
economic future.”
The Partnership, the leading national advocacy organization
focused on infusing 21st century skills into education, encourages the United
States to do a better job teaching and measuring advanced, 21st century skills
beyond simply assessing science and mathematics. In addition, the report
outlines several actions at the national, state and local levels that the
United States must implement to improve economic results and better prepare
citizens to participate in the 21st century. For a full set of recommendations
and the report itself:
http://www.21stcenturyskills.org/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=82&Itemid=40
Alabama’s Public Education Dilemma: Does Funding Influence Outcomes?
Like
most other states, Alabama devotes considerable resources to its public
education system. In the 2006–2007 school year, more than $3.7 billion was
spent on K–12 programs for 743,000 students in more than 1,500 schools in 130
school districts. Every year, the Alabama State Department of Education (ALSDE)
publishes reports on each school, district, and the entire education system in
order to track the academic progress of their students. The ALSDE uses a
variety of measures to chronicle its work, including the ever-present
cost-per-child, standardized test scores, teacher readiness, student-to-teacher
ratios, in-school violence reports, dropout rates, and poverty levels as they
are measured by students participating in free/reduced lunch programs.
Despite
this immense amount of readily available data, these reports do not attempt to
show the relationship between the ALSDE’s inputs—e.g., teacher readiness,
course difficulty, and teacher pay—and its outputs—graduation rates, standardized
test scores, and remedial education costs. Alabama’s Public Education Dilemma:
Does Funding Influence Outcomes? is the first of its kind in Alabama to examine
the relationship between a battery of educational inputs and the desired
outputs of academic proficiency, low dropout rates, and readiness for the
workforce and college.
Alabama’s
Public Education Dilemma: Does Funding Influence Outcomes? examines the
relationship between academic inputs and outputs in Alabama via two research
perspectives. The first perspective borrows heavily from a similar study
conducted by the Bluegrass Institute for Public Policy Solutions in 2006. “Bang
for the Buck: How Cost Effective are Kentucky’s Public Schools?” examined the
return on investment Kentucky’s public school system provided taxpayers by
looking at the standardized test scores of the Commonwealth’s best- and
worstperforming schools, controlling for per-student spending. Their scoring
method, known as the Score-Spending Index (SSI), is used in this report to make
school-by-school comparisons for a variety of standardized tests used in
Alabama, including the Alabama Reading and Mathematics Test (ARMT), the Alabama
Direct Assessment of Writing (ADAW), the ACT, and the Alabama High School
Graduation Exam (AHSGE).
The
second perspective of this report compares the state’s academic inputs and
outputs to those of the rest of the nation. While Alabama’s education standards
may look reasonably good to Alabamians, it would be myopic not to compare our
state’s levels of academic preparation to the remainder of the country.
State-by-state comparisons are made in this report for such inputs as course
difficulty, teacher salaries and benefits, and teacher-to-non-teacher ratios,
while outputs are compared for ACT scores, the National Assessment of
Educational Progress (NAEP), and high school graduation rates.
In
the words of the Bluegrass Institute’s study, this report aims to determine the
“bang for the buck” Alabamians are receiving from their public education
system, and the relationships—if any—between what our state devotes to
education and what it receives after being responsible for the dozen or so
years it has them in class.
Complete
report:
http://www.alabamapolicy.org/pdf/education-2007-final.pdf
Results of Kansas Teaching, Learning & Leadership (KANTeLL) Survey Presented to the State Board of Education
The interim report of the results of the Kansas Teaching,
Learning, & Leadership (KANTeLL) survey was presented to the State Board of
Education today by Eric Hirsch, New Teacher Center at the University of
California at Santa Cruz. The Kansas State Board of Education contracted with
the New Teacher Center last fall to conduct an online survey of Kansas
educators regarding overall working conditions, time, decision-making,
professional development and facilities and resources.
In
January, all Kansas teachers, principals, and licensed school-based educators
had the opportunity to privately and anonymously provide input on issues
critical to student learning. The United School Administrators of Kansas and
Kansas National Education Association partnered with the Kansas State Board of
Education and the Kansas State Department of Education in getting the word out
to educators regarding this survey. More than 16,600 Kansas educators (42
percent) from across the state participated in the KANTeLL survey. This
includes 14,868 teachers, 474 principals, 133 assistant principals and 1,179
other education professionals.
The results of the survey were very positive. The teachers
participating expressed the opinion that others in their districts look upon
them as educational experts. Teachers are involved in collaborative
decision-making and many school districts have put effective processes in place
so that teachers’ voices are heard.
Kansas educators also believe that their schools are good
places to work and learn as nine in ten teachers (89%) responding to this
survey indicate that they want to continue teaching at their school.
To access the complete report, go to www.kantell.org
School’s Making Me Sick!
With
summer ending and school underway, parents are transitioning from hearing their
children moan about not being able to swim everyday, to their child complaining
about homework, their new teachers or being in a different class than their
friends. Many parents also begin to hear more complaints of tummy aches and
headaches as a result of returning back to school.
The
psychological term for school-induced illnesses a child may develop when he or
she is trying to dodge school is School Avoidance, or School Refusal. Symptoms
include nausea, fatigue, headaches and abdominal pain. According to Lori
Crosby, Psy.D., Associate Professor, Pediatrics, Cincinnati Children’s Hospital
Medical Center, even if children start to complain about stomach aches and
other ailments, parents should still send their child to school unless they
have symptoms of fever or a contagious illness. “It would probably be helpful
to schedule a visit with the child’s pediatrician to rule out a ‘true’ medical
problem, which may give the parent the confidence to send their child when in
doubt,” said Dr. Crosby.
Approximately
1-5 percent of children in the United States suffer from School Avoidance. An
article in the American Family Physician states that School Avoidance/Refusal
should be considered when a student will not go to school and experiences
emotional distress of physical symptoms.
Dr.
Crosby says there are several reasons why a child may begin to display
characteristics of School Avoidance, among them are social problems such as
being bullied or isolated, having problems with learning, taking tests, giving
presentations, or the child being worried about family issues such as divorce,
moves, deaths, and/or a parent’s job changes/losses. Many young children
experience School Avoidance when they learn that they will be spending a lot of
time away from their families and their familiar settings.
Dr.
Crosby suggests that while School Avoidance is not out of the ordinary, parents
can seek professional counsel if they want to help their child overcome their
fears associated with attending school. “Brief counseling with a psychologist
or social worker may be helpful. In addition, parents should talk with school
personnel. Psychologists are very familiar with such issues and can be very
helpful with implementing a plan for the child,” she said.
Dr.
Crosby says that children who have School Avoidance issues usually go back and
forth between liking school and not liking it. “Often children with these
histories wax and wane in that they have good phases and more avoidant phases,”
she said. “Children usually start the year off with a great outlook about
attending school, and after a brief honeymoon of high hopes and good attendance
that lasts for a few days to a few months, they slide back into some School
Avoidance behaviors characterized by illness complaints,” said Crosby.
Children
may not outgrow their School Avoidance issues. However, Dr. Crosby says that
there are some actions that parents can take to help solve the problem.
“The
best approach is for parents to remain consistent with getting their child to
school, setting limits, and establishing a regular routine,” she said. “The
routine should be very predictable and consistent in the morning. Children
benefit from having everything ready and set out before they go to sleep which
reduces the morning rush,” Dr. Crosby says that this helps to reduce anxiety.
She adds that parents also need to be aware of their own anxiety related to
sending their child to school, because children pick up on subtle messages and
may use them to their advantage.
New Study Assesses the Impact of Soft Drink Availability in Elementary Schools on Consumption
he
consumption of soft drinks is generally considered to be a contributing factor
in childhood obesity. Because children spend a substantial amount of time at
school, the school food environment plays a central part in shaping eating
behaviors. While the availability of soft drinks in middle and high schools has
been investigated previously, a study published in the September 2008 issue of
the Journal of the American Dietetic Association systematically assesses
how the availability of soft drinks in elementary schools across the United
States relates to school-based and overall consumption. A broader question
raised by this investigation is how limiting soft drink availability at an
early age may alter eating behaviors over time.
While
the National School Breakfast and Lunch Programs are federally regulated, no
similar standards exist for "competitive foods," that is foods and
beverages sold through a la carte lines, vending machines, school stores and
school fund raisers. Guidelines and legislation to fill this gap have been
developing in private schools as well as at the school district- and
state-level. Voluntary sales restrictions are another new development, such as
the agreement reached between the Alliance for a Healthier Generation and the
American Beverage Association; Cadbury Schweppes; Coca-Cola and PepsiCo in May
2006. As a result, some school districts and even the states of California and
Connecticut have already banned soft drink sales in public elementary schools.
Meenakshi
M Fernandes, Pardee RAND Graduate School, Santa Monica, CA, analyzed data from
the Early Childhood Longitudinal Study from close to 11,000 fifth graders in
2,303 schools in 40 states. The study investigated socio-demographic
differences in how availability of soft drinks at elementary schools relates to
consumption of soft drinks at school and overall. Fernandes found that limiting
availability of soft drinks at school is associated with a 4% decrease in the
rate of any consumption overall.
However,
the author further reports that when soft drinks are available at school, about
one out of four children consume at least one soft drink over the course of a
week. For these children, school-based consumption represents about one-half
their total consumption. Black non-Hispanic and low-income children tend to
consume more. Furthermore, those consuming a high level of soft drinks at
school, typically low-income children and children attending rural schools, are
more likely to consume a higher level of soft drinks overall.
While
these findings suggest that soft drink availability at school may have limited
impact on overall consumption for elementary school children, a previous study
found that an additional serving of a non-diet soft drink per day can increase
body mass index among adolescents. Therefore, even a modest increase in daily
soft drink consumption could contribute to the development of obesity over the
course of adolescence, especially among vulnerable subgroups. Children in
elementary school often have less free time, less pocket money and more teacher
oversight regarding when and where they can go during school hours. Older
children are more likely to be affected by competitive foods at school.
Writing
in the article, Fernandes states, "While competitive food sales
restrictions at school are an important step in decreasing the consumption of
unhealthy foods, attention should also be granted to other approaches for
limiting availability or attenuating the relationship between availability and
consumption. Greater reductions in children's consumption of soft drinks will
require policy changes that go beyond food availability at school if we aim to
significantly reduce children's consumption of soft drinks."
Findings
based on this analysis can serve as a benchmark for future evaluations of the
effects of school food environment changes on eating behaviors. The author
stresses that further research into predictors of consumption, how children
respond to reduced availability, as well as food environments at home and at
school, may identify next steps towards improving the diet of children.
Impact
of school-based programs
According
to recent evidence school-based intervention programmes provide the best
results for reducing prevalence of childhood overweight and obesity if they are
performed with involvement of stakeholders and political support. In this
context physical activity education in schools, reducing television viewing and
nutritional education are examples of interventions that have been successful.
Reducing the consumption of sugar-added drinks has significant beneficial
effects on weight development.
Introduction
of school-based prevention programmes is justified for a number of reasons:
First, a large number of children can be monitored because most children attend
school and much of their eating and exercise takes place in school. Second, we
are able to influence children's behaviour towards the desired aim of healthy
living. Third, with intervention in school the peer group itself can be
supportive and enhance motivation. Moreover the teachers can function as a role
model and guide children's behaviour. The child itself should become part of
intervention and motivate family and friends to take part. According to present
evidence, all school-based interventions show some effects on either reducing
the BMI, the thickness of skin folds or in changing behaviour.
Ulm
Research on Metabolism, Exercise and Lifestyle in children (URMEL-ICE) is a
one-year school-based programme for the prevention of obesity and
cardiovascular risk factors in primary schools. The programme has been
established by an interdisciplinary working group at the Ulm University also
involving school teachers. The programme focuses on a reduction of TV-time,
intensive motivation of physical activity and reduction of energy rich drinks
as an integral part of daily education over a period of one school year. The
programme has been most effectively applied and shows beneficial effects on the
reduction of body fat mass. Children in the intervention group showed a mean
relative reduction of body fat mass by 260 g after the one year programme.
With
a further improvement in content of school-based programmes via parallel
interventions on various levels we hope to reduce the escalation of childhood
obesity.
Stereotypical
image of school bully needs updating, researchers say
The
stereotypical image of the school bully needs to be revised, researchers at the
Institute of Education, London, have concluded.
Less
than 1 per cent of primary school children are "true bullies", and
most children who bully are themselves bullied by other pupils, the researchers
say. Bullies are also more likely than their classmates to suffer from low
self-esteem, depression, and behavioural problems from early childhood and
through primary school. They are more likely to suffer from mental health
problems later in life too.
Dr
Leslie Gutman, lead author of the new study, believes that schools need to
teach that bullying is unacceptable and hold bullies to account for their
actions. However, she feels that there should also be greater awareness of the
wider possible consequences and causes of bullying behaviour.
The
study by the Centre for Research on the Wider Benefits of Learning (WBL) found
that 75 per cent of children enjoy healthy friendships. But the one in four who
does not may often have suffered from issues such as language delays, conduct
problems, and hyperactivity from an early age.
The
report highlights the value of existing government initiatives, such as peer
mentoring, the Social and Emotional Aspects of Learning programme, and national
strategies for targeting schools with bullying issues. However, Dr Gutman,
Research Director at WBL, says: "Early interventions that teach children coping
strategies for developmental difficulties such as hyperactivity may also
alleviate the later possibility of being targeted as victims and/or engaging in
bullying.
"We
are not suggesting that schools should adopt a soft approach to bullying but
simply stating that, on the basis of the evidence, bullying is a more complex
issue than some people believe it to be."
The
researchers used data from the Avon Longitudinal Study of Parents and Children
to study 6,500 pupils aged 8 to 11. They also found that children with happier
friendships are more likely to have married parents and more educated mothers.
Girls are more likely than boys to have larger numbers of friends, while boys
are more likely to be both bullies and victims.
Even
those who had friendships with which they were happy could have problems: in
particular, children who had friendships which were otherwise supportive, but
characterised by a high degree of conflict, tended to feel less in control of
their lives. The importance of social worlds: an investigation of peer
relationships Wider Benefits of Learning Report No 29 can be found at http://www.learningbenefits.net/Publications/ResRepIntros/ResRep29intro.htm
Interactivity
means more activity for students
The
British government has invested more money in Interactive Whiteboards (IWBs) in
its schools than any other government in the world. But is this huge investment
worth it? Have the new data projection technologies allowed students to learn
more effectively? This is the subject of recent research, funded by the
Economic and Social Research Council.
'These
IWBs have had a meteoric rise in popularity in schools,' says Sara Hennessy who
carried out the project with Rosemary Deaney of Cambridge University. 'But,
until recently, assumptions about how they have transformed teaching were not
based on hard evidence.'
The
system consists of a computer linked to a data projector and a large
touch-sensitive board, which displays images, graphics, animations and videos.
You can write captions directly onto the board and instantly convert your
handwriting to type. You can create suspense by hiding and revealing text and
graphics.
They
can also be used with a special camera so that pupils can develop their own
written ideas and images, and then share them with the class by projecting
their work onto the IWB.
'We
explored how teachers might use projection technology to give space, time and
status to pupils' contributions to lessons. We wanted to look at the ways in
which it could be used to challenge and develop pupils' thinking,' Dr Hennessy
says. The research also discusses the dangers of technology-driven teaching and
warns that time constraints can lead to superficial use of the technology.
In
the study, English, history, mathematics and science teachers used interactive
whiteboards and data projectors in various ways.
·
Circling
and highlighting make complex ideas more concrete and draw attention to
particular features
·
Spotlighting,
enlarging and zooming can help to investigate detail and keep attention on key
concepts
·
Dragging
and dropping are used to classify objects.
·
Provide
new opportunities for learners to express themselves publicly, receive critical
feedback and reformulate their thoughts.
·
Stimulate
discussion.
·
Allow
teachers to adapt to individual learning needs.
The
project has provoked interest from academics, trainees and teacher educators. A
series of 5 interactive CD-ROMs have been developed for teachers. These are
designed to stimulate debate around key issues rather than offering models of
'best practice' and they are already proving influential in teacher education.
The researchers are confident that the project will be welcomed by policymakers
seeking a return on investment.
'We
have shown that in the right hands the IWB can be a motivating and immensely
powerful tool,' says Dr Hennessy. 'It allows teachers and pupils to build and
test complex ideas together, and supports active learning in new ways.'
Houghton Mifflin Reading
The National Center for Education
Evaluation and Regional Assistance within The Institute of Education Sciences
has released a new intervention report from the What Works Clearinghouse. The subject of the report is the "Houghton
Mifflin Reading" system, a reading program for instruction in grades K-6
that uses big books (authentic literature), anthologies, read-alouds, and audio
compact discs to provide step-by-step instruction in reading.
To browse, download and print the
report, please visit:
http://ies.ed.gov/ncee/wwc/reports/beginning_reading/houghton/
High School Sports Participation Increases Again; Boys, Girls and Overall Participation Reach All-time Highs
FOR
IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Contact: Bruce Howard or John Gillis
INDIANAPOLIS,
IN (September 4, 2008) - For the 19th consecutive year, the number of
student participants in high school athletics increased in 2007-08, according
to the National Federation of State High School Associations (NFHS).
Based
on figures from the 50 state high school athletic/activity associations, plus
the District of Columbia, that are members of the NFHS, participation for the
2007-08 school year set an all-time high of 7,429,381, according to the 2007-08
High School Athletics Participation Survey conducted by the NFHS. In addition,
boys and girls participation figures reached all-time highs, with 3,057,266
girls and 4,372,115 boys participating in 2007-08. The girls figure surpassed
the total of 3,021,807 set last year, while the boys figure eclipsed the former
record of 4,367,442 set in 1977-78.
Through
the survey, it was also determined that 54.8 percent of students enrolled in
high schools participate in athletics.
Competitive
spirit squads gained the most female participants in 2007-08 with 16,130,
followed by soccer with 8,913 and cross country with 6,973.
Lacrosse
gained the most participants among boys sports in 2007-08 with 11,336, followed
by soccer with 5,562, swimming and diving with 5,158 and cross country with
5,042.
In
terms of combined participation, the emerging sports of bowling and lacrosse
continued their rise in popularity with significant percentage increases.
Overall participation in bowling increased 17 percent, while lacrosse
participation was up 14 percent.
Basketball
remained the most popular sport for girls with 449,450 participants, followed
by outdoor track and field (447,520), volleyball (397,968), fast pitch softball
(371,293), soccer (346,545), cross country (190,349), tennis (172,455),
swimming and diving (147,197), competitive spirit squads (111,307) and golf
(69,243).
In
boys sports, 11-player football once again topped the list with 1,108,286
participants, followed by basketball (552,935), outdoor track and field
(548,821), baseball (478,029), soccer (383,561), wrestling (259,688), cross
country (221,109), golf (159,958), tennis (156,285) and swimming and diving
(111,896).
Texas
held its title as having the most sports participants with 779,049, followed by
California (735,497), New York (380,870), Ohio (346,571), Illinois (336,646),
Michigan (315,734), Pennsylvania (286,992), New Jersey (256,837), Minnesota
(230,068) and Florida (227,157).
The
participation survey has been compiled since 1971 by the NFHS through numbers
it receives from its member associations. The complete 2007-08 Participation
Survey is available here:
http://www.nfhs.org/core/contentmanager/uploads/2007-08%20Participation%20Survey.pdf
Improving
Arts Education Is Key to Stemming Audience Decline, RAND Study Finds
Policymakers
have underestimated the critical role of arts learning in supporting a vibrant
nonprofit cultural sector, according to a RAND Corporation study.
Despite
decades of effort to make high-quality works of art available to Americans,
demand for the arts has failed to keep pace with supply. Audiences for
classical music, jazz, opera, theater and the visual arts have declined as a
percentage of the population, and the percentage of these audiences age 30 and
younger has fallen even more.
Calling
upon evidence that experiencing and studying the arts in childhood increase the
likelihood of arts participation later in life, the study urges policymakers in
both the arts and education to devote greater attention to cultivating demand
for the arts by supporting more and better arts education.
Synthesizing
previous studies, researchers find long-term involvement in the arts is most
likely to be stimulated by arts education that develops a range of individual
capacities:
- the ability to see, hear and feel what works of art have to offer
- the ability to create within an art form
- the historical and cultural knowledge that enriches the understanding of
works of art
- the ability to draw meaning from works of art through reflection and
discussion with others.
National
and state arts content standards in music, the visual arts, theater and dance
embody just such a comprehensive approach to teaching the arts. But the study
finds evidence that relatively few American youth are getting this kind of
education.
At
the public school level, researchers note, arts content standards have been
almost universally mandated by the states and are broadening teaching
practices, but state, local, and district policies are not providing the
resources or time in the school day to implement these standards. In fact,
there is evidence that No Child Left Behind has led to reduced class time for
both the arts and humanities in the past five years, according to the study.
Arts organizations and colleges have been helpful in complementing school-based
arts education, but it is not enough to fill the void. "In the past couple
of decades, these programs have proliferated and improved, but they cannot
substitute for strong, sequential arts education in the schools," Zakaras
said.
Analyzing
grantmaking data, researchers show that state arts agencies, which have
historically focused on providing grants to arts organizations, have directed
less than 10 percent of their grants over the last 20 years toward activities that
target arts learning. In most states, the grants are not part of a
comprehensive strategy to promote youth or adult arts learning.
However,
some state arts agencies are bucking this trend. Rhode Island and New Jersey,
for example, have forged relationships with their state departments of
education, other state agencies and members of the arts community to develop a
comprehensive statewide plan for improving arts education in the public
schools.
In
New Jersey, the state's arts agency helped develop a survey of arts education
that has raised awareness of the inadequacy of its provision in the schools.
Concerned residents are now pushing for the adoption of a number of new
policies, including inclusion of per-pupil arts spending in New Jersey's
Comparative Spending Guide for public schools. In Rhode Island, the state arts
agency was instrumental in successful efforts to adopt a standards-based high
school graduation requirement in the arts.
Based
on these findings, the authors recommend that state arts agencies and
policymakers gauge how well their states are doing by conducting surveys of
arts education; developing specific high school graduation requirements in the
arts; recognizing and publicizing arts learning programs considered exceptional
by experts in the field; and advocating for changes in state policy that
increase the amount and breadth of arts learning opportunities.
"For
policy change to happen at the state level, the entire arts community needs to
get behind it. Arts educators can't do it by themselves. But if they were
joined by other policymakers, including directors of arts organizations and the
civic leaders who sit on their boards, who knows what they might be able to
accomplish?" Zakaras said.
According
to the authors, a healthy demand for the arts is critical to a vibrant
nonprofit arts sector. Policies that focus on supporting the supply of the arts
and broadening access to the arts are not sufficient for building that demand.
The
full report, "Cultivating Demand for the Arts: Arts Learning, Arts
Engagement, and State Arts Policy," and a report summary are available at http://www.rand.org and http://www.wallacefoundation.org
Kids
Will Eat Fruits and Vegetables at School – with a Little Help
Researchers
at the University of Maryland have announced initial data that shows
school-based intervention efforts help kids buck a national trend by increasing
their consumption of fruits and vegetables. To the researchers’ knowledge,
these results are the first for Maryland, and on the leading edge nationally
and internationally.
Dr.
Bonnie Braun heads the team, which investigated the effects of school, family
and community environments on the food-related behavior of elementary
schoolchildren. Braun is an associate professor in Department of Family Science
at the university’s School of Public Health and holds an appointment with the
University of Maryland Cooperative Extension (MCE), part of the College of
Agriculture & Natural Resources (AGNR).
The
research is part of a series of studies under Project FRESH, a school-based
nutrition education program designed to increase fruit and vegetable
consumption—especially of products grown by Maryland-producers - among
elementary school children. The project is conducted by the University of
Maryland Cooperative Extension Food Stamp Nutrition Education program, with MCE
educators providing the curriculum and teacher education. Funding is provided
by AGNR, the Maryland Department of Human Resources and the U.S. Department of
Agriculture.
“Fruits
and vegetables are a key contributor to children’s health,” says Braun.
“Unfortunately, national reports indicate that children’s consumption of these
foods normally decreases from kindergarten to fifth grade. Students from
low-income families are particularly at risk of inadequate intake.” Many of
these children are dependent on food served by the school for one-third to
two-thirds of their daily food intake. However, even if schools increase fruits
and vegetables on their cafeteria lines, children must be willing to eat them.
That’s
why Braun and her team focused their research on schools where 50 percent or
more of the students are eligible for free or reduced-price meals. They
investigated the relationship between exposure to fruits and vegetables, taste
preference and actual consumption among three groups of fourth-grade students
in the Baltimore-Washington Metro area. “Our hypothesis was that school-based
interventions, focused on increasing children’s preference for fruits and
vegetables, would be associated with an increase in consumption both in school
and at home,” says Braun.
The
three types of interventions involved teacher training with a tested curriculum
and parent events, teacher’s use of the curriculum without events involving
parents, and an Extension educator teaching in student classrooms. All three
approaches produced similar results, which supported the researchers’
hypothesis. They found that repeated exposure - through taste testing - to
fruits and vegetables matters, and that even moderate interventions, focused on
repeated tasting, make a difference.
Prior
to the interventions, more than nine out of ten students (93 percent) were not
eating the recommended five fruits and vegetables a day; seven out of ten (70
percent) ate fewer than three servings of fruits and vegetables daily; and of
those, more than half (56 percent) ate fewer than two servings.
After
the interventions, six out of ten (60 percent) students increased their taste
for fruits and vegetables, and half (50 percent) either maintained their
higher-than-average intake or increased intake.
In
a complementary effort, Dr. Josué López, MCE urban agriculture educator in Baltimore
City, is working with Extension’s Expanded Food and Nutrition Education Program
(EFNEP) and 4-H to conduct education programs related to vegetable gardening
for city youth. Some of these programs involve the creation of vegetable
gardens and the construction and maintenance of “salad tables” (large
table-like containers on which lettuce and other vegetables can be grown) at
schools and community centers. The salad table work stemmed from last year’s
“Leveraging Extension” mini-grant program. As they cultivate their gardens,
youngsters develop an appreciation for produce.
National Poll on Children’s Health
As
the new school year begins, many parents with overweight and obese children are
worried about how their kids will be treated by other students on the
playground and in the classroom.
Bullying
is a major concern among parents with overweight and obese children ages 6
to13, and these parents are much more likely than parents with healthy weight
children to rate bullying as a top health issue for kids, according to a report
released today by the University of Michigan C.S. Mott Children’s Hospital
National Poll on Children’s Health.
“We
found that parents with overweight or obese children actually view bullying as
a greater problem than childhood obesity,” says Matthew M. Davis, M.D.,
M.A.P.P., director of the National Poll on Children’s Health. “Since bullying
is known to be a problem for children with increased weight, bullying
prevention programs will need to be mindful of obesity as a potential trigger
for bullying behavior, and of parents’ concerns surrounding this issue.”
And
parents aren’t taking childhood obesity lightly. The National Poll on
Children’s Health recently reported that parents across the country now rank
childhood obesity as their No. 1 health concern for kids.
While
parents are having discussions with their children about limiting junk food,
time spent watching TV and videos, and playing computer games, the latest
National Poll on Children’s Health report reveals that only about two-thirds of
parents with overweight or obese children actually enforce such limits.
Regardless, Davis says talking with your child about making healthier diets and
increased physical activity is still a very important first step in setting the
stage for a healthier lifestyle.
The
National Poll on Children’s Health finds:
• 30 percent of parents with
overweight or obese children do not set limits on TV, video games or computer
games.
• Parents of overweight or obese children were more likely to rate
neightborhood safety and lack of opportunities for physical activity as top
health concerns for kids
• 39 percent of families polled include one or
more overweight or obese child who is between the ages of 6 and 13.
• 52
percent of families with obese children and 49 percent of families with
overweight children include an obese parent. Only 26 percent of families with
all healthy weight children report having an obese parent.
In
addition to providing insight about health concerns and behaviors reported by
parents with obese and overweight children, the National Poll on Children’s
Health
report also offers a closer look at the connection between
parents’ weight and their children’s weight.
The
poll shows that children who are obese or overweight are almost twice as likely
to have an obese parent than heathy weight children.
“In
many families, obesity is a two-generation phenomenon among parents and their
children. This trend could be the the result of genetics, or behaviors such as
eating habits and physical activity that are shared among parents and their
children,” says Davis, associate professor of general pediatrics and internal
medicine at the U-M Medical School, and associate professor of public policy at
the U-M Gerald R. Ford School of Public Policy.
For
the complete report and podcast about poll results, visit the C.S. Mott
Children’s Hospital National Poll on Children’s Health online at http://www.med.umich.edu/mott/npch.
School Vouchers and Student Achievement: Recent Evidence, Remaining Questions. 2008.
In
this article, the authors review the empirical evidence on the impact of
education vouchers on student achievement, and briefly discuss the evidence
from other forms of school choice. The best research to date finds relatively
small achievement gains for students offered education vouchers, most of which
are not statistically different from zero. Further, what little evidence exists
regarding the potential for public schools to respond to increased competitive
pressure generated by vouchers suggests that one should remain wary that large
improvements would result from a more comprehensive voucher system. The
evidence from other forms of school choice is also consistent with this
conclusion.
Many
questions remain unanswered, however, including whether vouchers have
longer-run impacts on outcomes such as graduation rates, college enrollment, or
even future wages, and whether vouchers might nevertheless provide a cost
neutral alternative to our current system of public education provision at the
elementary and secondary school level.
Prepared
for publication in Annual Review of Economics , Vol. 1 (2009)
Complete
report:
http://ncspe.org/publications_files/OP163.pdf
Charter Schools Supported by Public
Americans
strongly embrace having charter school and other choice options other than
their assigned schools, and believe that multiple avenues of delivery are best,
according to a compendium of polling released by The Center for Education
Reform. The summary of three years of national and state polling demonstrates
that support grows with knowledge, and when presented with information in a
clear, neutral way about various reform ideas, support is both high and deep.
For
example:
·
While
most Americans do not know what a charter school is, given a clear definition,
78% of Americans support "allowing communities to create new public
schools – called charter schools – that would be held accountable for student
results and would be required to meet the same academic standards and testing
requirements as other public schools."
·
State
by state, the awareness of and support for charter schools is higher in states
with stronger charter laws and higher levels of media coverage.
·
Issues
such as performance pay, which is growing in support among teachers and will be
a major shift in union contracts in cities such as Washington, DC, is favorably
viewed by 59% of those surveyed.
·
The
conventional notion of zip code based assignment is rejected by a majority of
adults. Fully, 69% of Americans surveyed reject requiring children to attend
one public school based solely on where they live.
·
Not
surprisingly, safety is of utmost concern to Americans, 78% of whom would be
very or somewhat likely to remove their child from a school if the child felt
unsafe.
An
annual poll by the Gallup organization in partnership with a traditional
education group and released last week reported much less support among
Americans. "Our data, coupled with extensive analysis of polling on
education reform over the years, confirm what we know from our day-to-day work
in American communities – that the people want immediate opportunities for
children that work, regardless of what it is called or if it is outside of what
they have grown up to view as traditional public education," said CER
president Jeanne Allen.
"The
public supports education, and not just through one kind of system," Allen
noted. "We are encouraged by increasing attention in the presidential race
but are far from saturated with what should be considered the most important
global issue of our time."
Complete
report:
http://edreform.com/_upload/CST_poll2008.pdf
|